Wednesday, 17 September 2014
facebook  twitter  google  icon   youtube rss 

Neglect and disregard for life in Israeli prisons

The Israeli Prison Service maintains a systematic policy of medical negligence toward Palestinian detainees.

Israel tortures Gazans, targets Palestinian rights defenders

As part of its systematic detention policy against Palestinians since June, Israel is also torturing...

Expulsion order for PLC member Khalida Jarrar expires

Victory - the Israeli military deportation order expelling PLC member Khalida Jarrar from Ramallah t...

32 Palestinians arrested overnight, including 13 children

32 Palestinians were arrested overnight in East Jerusalem and the West Bank, of whom 13 are children...

48 new housing units in northern West Bank settlement

A new neighbourhood in the northern West Bank settlement of Har Bracha was inaugurated last Thursday...
aicafe-16-september
Please join us at the AICafe on Tuesday 16 September from 7.30 p.m. for Sabra and Shatila with Basem Sbaih.
act-no-2020-uefa-european-championships-in-jerusalem
Urgent, act now! Tell UEFA to exclude Israel from the bidding to host matches for the UEFA European Football Championship 2020. Hosting decisions will be...

Jerusalem

32 Palestinians arrested overnight, including 13 children...

32 Palestinians were arrested overnight in East Jerusalem and the West Bank, of whom 13 are children.

Readmore

32 Palestinians arrested overnight, including 13 children

Hebron

PHOTOS: Protest halts Israeli archaeological dig in Hebron...

Activists succeeded in temporarily halting Israel's archeological dig in Hebron's Tel Rumeida. As in other occupied Palestinian territory, such as Eas...

Readmore

PHOTOS: Protest halts Israeli archaeological dig in Hebron

Opinions

Live now as we think humans should live...

People ask me about politics and claim it is too complex. I say it is simple and predictable.

Readmore

Live now as we think humans should live

Politico

Israeli Society

Economy of the Occupation

Human Rights

#youtube

#Facebook


Error
  • JUser: :_load: Unable to load user with ID: 64

Palestinian right of return: Abu Mazen gave up? So what?

Created on 05 November 2012

In the colonial context of the Israeli mind, every Palestinian step backwards strengthens the position of those, who today represent the majority in Israel, who aspire to destroy Palestine. The history of the past three decades of negotiations demonstrates beyond any doubt that in the present relation of forces, compromises lead to additional pressures and to even more compromises. The only efficient counter-strategy should be: no compromise at all on our rights, even if it may take years to achieve freedom and return. Change the relation of forces and then negotiate, otherwise it is not a negotiation but a mere diktat.

 

 Palestinian_refugeesPalestinian_refugees 

The right of Palestinian refugees to return is an individual right guaranteed in international law (Photo: Fred Csasznik) 


In an interview to Israeli Chanel 2, Palestinian President Mahmud Abbas declared that he renounces his right to return back to the city of Safed, where he was born and from where he was expelled and became a refugee. In fact, the Palestinian president expressed more than a personal declaration; as in several previous occasions, Abu Mazen attempted to calm Israeli public opinion on the central issue of Palestinian refugee rights, and to reduce the Israeli-Palestinian conflict into a conflict over territory, borders and sovereignty.

 

While the Israeli right will not be seduced by Abbas’ statement, the left will attempt to use it to show that the Palestinian leadership takes into consideration the Israeli fear of a "demographic threat" and accepts Israel as a Jewish state. 

 

While Abu Mazen has the right to give up his dream to return to Safed and even to live in Tel Aviv (if and when Israeli laws will permit it), he cannot speak on behalf of millions of other refugees who have never abdicated this right. This is so for three main reasons: first, the right to return and to get back one's property is an individual right, and each and every Palestinian will decide what to do with his/her stolen property, as well as if s/he intends to live on that property, to rent it or to sell it. Second, the right of return is a fundamental human right. Third, the right of return of the Palestinian refugees is part of international law and recognized by several UN resolutions; one can renounce the implementation of a right, but not the right itself. Even the state of Israel was obliged to express support for UN resolution 194 in order to be accepted as a member state in the United Nations.

 

Abu Mazen’s statement may satisfy (although not completely, as always happen when one gives his finger in order to try and save the hand), but the price he is paying is extremely high: the great majority of Palestinian public opinion is angry, including within Abbas’ own party, and for many he has crossed the line of loyalty to his own people.

 

As an Israeli, I am not the one to decide what is loyalty to the Palestinian people and their inalienable rights. However, as an Israeli I can evaluate the miscalculation of the Palestinian president: in the colonial context of the Israeli mind, every Palestinian step backwards strengthens the position of those – and today they represent the majority in Israel – who aspire to destroy Palestine. "More pressure, more compromise" – this has been the Zionist strategy for decades already. The history of the past three decades of negotiations demonstrates beyond any doubt that in the present relation of forces, compromises lead to additional pressures and to even more compromises.

 

The only efficient counter-strategy should be: no compromise at all on our rights, even if it may take years to achieve freedom and return. This is not a maximalist strategy of "everything or nothing", but a matter of political realism, pragmatism even: change the relation of forces and then negotiate, otherwise it is not a negotiation but a mere diktat.